Caffeine
A Madison integrated marketing agency with six published senior staff, delivering SEO and analytics alongside strategy, advertising, web, content, PR and social media.
Hub Score v2.0
60/100
Limited public profile
Top 50%The structured capability record is narrow; verify fit before shortlisting.
Tied #185 with 20 other companies of 399 listed United States companies.
Entry retainer
Not published
No recurring floor published; confirm current scope
Operating history
Not published
Founding year not published
Documented breadth
8 services
4 industry categories
Evidence confidence
80% · High
360 comparable industry peers
Website traffic
No public estimate
HypeStat · Checked 7 Sep 2026
Traffic context: No defensible current public traffic estimate was recorded; this display-only field does not affect Hub Score. Traffic is display-only and does not affect Hub Score.
Open HypeStat sourceBuyer decision brief
Where the public evidence points
Caffeine publishes an exact Madison office and six senior staff spanning strategy, accounts, content, development and creative work. SEO and analytics sit inside a genuinely integrated offer, but the reviewed company page does not establish founding year, price or three dated SEO outcomes.
Published Madison office
Six named senior specialists
Integrated search, content and web capabilities
Relative context
How Caffeine compares
Compared with 360 United States profiles sharing at least one documented industry.
| Measure | Company | Peer median |
|---|---|---|
| Entry retainer floor | Not published | $1.5k/mo |
| Years operating | Not published | Not published |
| Hub Score v2.0 | 60 | 60 |
| Evidence confidence | 80% | 95% |
Peer comparisons are computed from the current directory dataset, not external market estimates.
Documented services
Linked capabilities are included only when documented in the company research record.
Documented industries
Industry inclusion signals public experience, not exclusive specialisation.
Verified profile evidence
Products and operating claims
Published Madison office
The company publishes 897 Boston Post Road, Madison, CT 06443 and describes Madison as its home.
Official company page
Six named senior staff
The company page names Bill Mulligan, Katie Tuttle, Matt Sawyers, Sam Tuttle, Donavon Young and Eric Webb across senior roles.
Official team section
SEO and analytics
SEO and analytics are listed together as an integrated marketing capability.
Official capability list
Web and mobile delivery
Website design and development plus mobile applications are published capabilities.
Official capability list
Content and public relations
Content marketing and public relations are included in the service mix.
Official capability list
Strategy, advertising and social
The company lists strategy and planning, advertising and collateral, social media and direct marketing.
Official capability list
First-party case evidence
Published client outcomes
Transparent scoring
Why Hub Score v2.0 is 60
Operating resilience
0/153 points under 3 years; 6 at 3-5; 9 at 6-10; 11 at 11-15; 13 at 16-20; 15 at 21+ years.
Delivery capability
25/25A monotonic diminishing-return curve: 1 service = 6, 2 = 10, 3 = 14, 4 = 17, 5 = 20, 6 = 22, 7+ = 25.
Sector evidence
18/25Industry coverage contributes 10, 14, 16 or 18 points; 1, 2 or 3+ source-linked case studies add 3, 5 or 7 points.
Commercial clarity
14/204 for a live site + 6 for a disclosed entry floor + 5 for a stated pricing model + 5 for a specific best-fit client statement.
Delivery capacity
3/15Team bands map monotonically: 10-20 = 5, 20-50 = 8, 50-150 = 11, 150-250 = 13, 250-500 or 500+ = 15.
The five capability factors total exactly 100. Evidence Confidence is calculated and displayed separately. See sources, guardrails and formulas →
Questions for the sales call
- Confirm the current Madison team and identify the specialist accountable for technical and organic search work.
- Request three dated SEO cases with baselines, measurement periods and attributable conversions.
- Document recurring price, channel allocation, implementation responsibility, reporting and exit ownership.
What this profile does not prove
- Three complete dated SEO cases were not established. Capability listings do not establish measured client outcomes.
- Founding year is not published on the reviewed company page.
- No comparable recurring SEO price or standard workload is public.